Response to the NY Times Article about Kiva
Published by Jerry Ostradicky, | 11 Nov 2009 at 11:09 pm
Casey Wilson recently had a great email that she sent out about the recent articles about Kiva in the NY times that I thought was worth posting:
You might have read Stephanie Strom’s article “Confusion Where Money Lent via Kiva Goes” in the New York Times a few days ago. This issue has been making the rounds since David Roodman’s post a month ago. As a fellow “peer-to-peer” microfinance organization, we thought it was important for us to follow up with our own supporters on this issue.
To be clear, contributions on Wokai go to microfinance institutions (our “Field Partners”) in rural China, who are in charge of distributing the loans to the borrowers and collecting repayment. A borrower can in fact receive a loan from a Field Partner prior the time the loan is “100% funded” on the Wokai website. Below are two excerpts from Wokai’s FAQ that might shed more light on the issue.
Can a recipient’s loan start before it is 100% funded?
Yes. Once a Field Partner has posted a recipient’s profile online, Wokai Field Partners can use their own capital to issue that recipient’s loan. Wokai then reimburses this capital to the Field Partner once the recipient’s loan has been 100% funded. If the recipient’s loan is canceled for any reason, the recipient will no longer be designated as a “Wokai recipient†and that Field Partner will permanently fund the loan with its own capital reserves.
What happens if a recipient’s loan does not get 100% funded by the final fundraising day?
If a recipient’s loan is not 100% funded by the time it reaches zero “Days Left”, then Wokai will either extend the recipient’s fundraising period by one month or, if there is any specific reason why contributors are choosing not to fund the recipient, Wokai will cancel the recipient and allow contributors to select a new recipient to support.
Wokai is committed to being transparent in its processes. To that end, we discuss our field partner relationships right on our “About” pages. We even received credit from David Roodman in his original post for being very open about our relationships with field partners.
To read more about what Wokai does, visit their site at Wokai.org